Fun,
First, and Unique Facts
By George Painter
© Copyright, George Painter 2004
Alabama
1822 Despite
a clear law adopting the English common law (which makes sodomy a crime), the
Alabama Supreme Court rules that the common law is not in effect in the state.
Because there is no specific sodomy law at the time, this prohibits
prosecution for sodomy in the state. In 1830, the Court reverses itself.
1854 Alabama
enacts the nation’s first law giving a spouse the right to sue for divorce
if the other spouse committed sodomy, either before or after the marriage.
1933 Alabama
enacts a unique law banning a “conspiracy to commit the crime against
nature.” This law is not defined and it is unclear if there ever was a
prosecution.
1935 The
Alabama legislature passes a revised sterilization law to cover any “sexual
pervert, Sadist, homosexualist, Masochist, Sodomist, or any other grave form
of sexual perversion [sic].” Concerned that there are not sufficient
due process guarantees in the bill, Governor Bibb Graves asks the Alabama
Supreme Court for an advisory opinion. The Court agrees with the Governor that
the bill would be unconstitutional on due process grounds. When the
legislature adds due process guarantees, Governor Graves, who has changed from
a sterilization supporter to an opponent, vetoes the bill again. The
legislature never enacts this bill.
1952 An
escaped prisoner caused the word “homosexual” to appear in a U.S. Supreme
Court decision for the first time. A man fled Alabama for Ohio and tried to
prevent his return to the Alabama prisons, claiming he had been used as a
“gal-boy” by the “homosexuals among the prisoners.” The Court rules
against him.
1984 An
Alabama appellate court upholds a sodomy conviction after a trial in which the
mother of a 17-year-old partner was permitted to ask “what men can do with
other men.”
Alaska
1867 When
the United States buys Alaska from the Russians, Alaska has no criminal laws
whatsoever. Five years before, the Russian Czar, in a fit of anger,
revoked all Russian law there. Not
only is sodomy therefore legal, but so where murder, rape, arson, and every
other crime. This situation
remains for 17 years after purchase by the U.S. until Congress enacted a law
to give some stability to Alaska.
1955 Alaska
enacts the nation’s first law forbidding the sale of comic books that
portray “sexually indecent subject matter such as adultery, homo-sexuality,
sadism, masochism or other perversions.”
1971 The
Alaska legislature, thinking it is removing surplus language in a clean-up of
state law, accidentally legalizes oral sex.
When pointed out to it by the Alaska Supreme Court, the legislature
makes no effort to correct the “error” and later repeals the remaining
portion of the sodomy law.
American
Samoa
1963 A new
criminal code based on the laws of Georgia is enacted, which excludes Lesbians
from prosecution for sodomy. American Samoa had had no law against sodomy
since its acquisition by the U.S. in 1899.
Arizona
1913 Just
seven months after the Arizona Supreme Court ruled that the common-law
definition of sodomy did not permit prosecutions for fellatio, the legislature
changed the law. Although a complete recompilation of state law was adopted,
in which the compiler was denied “any power to change or modify or make any
law or laws,” the sodomy law was changed to include “the penetration of
the mouth of any human being by the organ of any male person.” Another new
law adopted in the Code was that a wife was considered competent to testify
against her husband, but not vice versa, in a trial for “the crime against
nature, or any similar offense[.]”
1944 The
Arizona Supreme Court is the first in the nation to receive a sodomy case in
which an explicit right to privacy is raised. The Court did not address the
claim; it merely ignored it.
1962 The
Arizona Supreme Court upholds a conviction in the only known published sodomy
case in which a man arrested for sodomy accuses the arresting officer of being
attracted to other men.
Arkansas
1864 Arkansas
eliminates the existing racial discrimination in the penalty for sodomy by
raising the penalty to death for everyone. No death sentences are carried out
under the law, however. This law, though found in the state’s session laws,
is not found in any published code for the state, either having been
overlooked by a compiler, or intentionally ignored due to embarrassment.
1950 Although
there are many hundreds of reported sodomy cases in the United States, many of
which give much personal detail, an Arkansas case this year is the only one in
U.S. history that mentions the circumcision status of a partner in a male-male
encounter.
1955 Arkansas
lowers its minimum penalty for sodomy from five years to one year, noting that
juries were reluctant to convict defendants with such a severe penalty.
1975 Arkansas
becomes the first Southern state to repeal its consensual sodomy law when it
enacts a comprehensive criminal code revision. However, in 1977, during Anita
Bryant’s anti-Gay crusade, it reinstates the law, this time as applicable
only to people of the same sex.
California
1801 Though
carried out under Spanish law, the last known U.S. death sentence for sodomy
occurs in California. Eighteen-year-old Jose Antonio Rosas is shot by a firing
squad.
1850 California’s
first criminal code is enacted, and includes a ban on sodomy. The law begins
with the preface, “The People of the State of California, represented in
Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:”. However, the law was enacted in
April when California still was a territory. It did not become a state until
September, and it is unclear if this made the original law invalid.
1897 The
California Supreme Court upholds the sodomy convictions of two prisoners for
relations with each other in their cell, the first published U.S. case dealing
with sex in a prison.
1909 California
is the first state to adopt a sterilization law covering “sexual
perverts.”
1915 A
California appellate court is the first in the nation to ponder, in a written
opinion, the nature of human sexuality in a sodomy case.
1915 California
expands its sodomy law by enacting a law against oral sex. This unique law
actually outlawed the acts of “fellatio” and “cunnilingus,” the first
uses of these words in a U.S. statute. Four years later, the California
Supreme Court struck down the law, saying that “fellatio” and
“cunnilingus” are not words of ordinary use in the English language,
something California law requires. The legislature responds by outlawing
“oral copulation.”
1919 A
California appellate court upholds a sodomy conviction that followed a
mother’s drilling holes in her 14-year-old son’s bedroom wall to see what
he was doing with a partner.
1925 A
California appellate court upholds a sodomy conviction that is the first case
in the nation to mention condoms found in the home as evidence admitted
against the defendant.
1927 A
California appellate court upholds a sodomy conviction that followed a
mother’s hiring a private detective to hide under the bed of her son’s
partner and burst out during their sex.
1939 California
enacts the nation’s first law requiring revocation of a teacher’s license
if the teacher is convicted of sodomy or oral copulation.
1947 California
is the first state in the nation to enact a “sex offender registration
law.” It requires registration and reports of changes of address of persons
convicted of sex offenses, including consensual sodomy and oral copulation.
1951 A
California appellate court rules that Gay men are vagrant per se, permitting
them to be jailed without committing any criminal act.
1962 The
California Supreme Court is the first in the nation to find a right to privacy
in enclosed restroom stalls, reversing convictions for consensual sodomy
occurring therein. Many other state courts follow this decision.
1969 California
enacts a unique law, signed by Governor Ronald Reagan, permitting the
treatment of sexual psychopaths by means of prayer alone.
Colorado
1945 The
Colorado Supreme Court, in upholding a sodomy conviction, becomes the first in
the nation to refer to the defendant as “queer” in its opinion.
1974 The
Colorado Supreme Court is the first in the nation to strike down an
“offensive solicitation” provision, common in new criminal codes enacted
in the early 1970s, that was designed as an exception to the decriminalization
of sodomy.
Connecticut
1656 New
Haven Colony (later merged into Connecticut) adopts the first law in what
became the United States specifically to outlaw sex between two women.
There are no prosecutions under the law, which is a capital offense.
1821 A
revision of the state’s colonial-era sodomy law reduces the penalty from
death to life imprisonment and, probably unwittingly makes two other changes
to the law. First, it is worded uniquely that either sex can be the
perpetrator, but only a male can be a victim. Second, it refers to “carnal
knowledge of a man,” thus probably becoming the first state to outlaw
fellatio.
1863 The
Connecticut Supreme Court is the first in the nation to find that deadly force
is allowable to prevent an act of sodomy.
1891 The
Connecticut Supreme Court affirms a lower court in granting damages to a man
for the injury his teenage son suffered from a sexual relationship with
another teenage boy.
1970 Connecticut’s
Commissioner of Motor Vehicles John Tynan denies a driver’s license to a man
with a sodomy conviction on his record, saying the man “is an admitted
homosexual” and “his homosexuality makes him an improper person to hold an
operator’s license.” Connecticut Attorney General Robert Killian upholds
Tynan’s decision. The man denied his license later commits suicide.
Delaware
1905 Delaware
becomes the last state in the nation to eliminate time in the pillory for acts
of sodomy.
1918 A
Delaware appellate court becomes the first court in the nation to rule that a
solicitation to commit sodomy is not an attempt to commit it.
1962 The
Delaware Supreme Court rules that the state’s strict ban on probation for
sodomy can be ignored by courts.
District
of Columbia
1858 Though
it was merely one part of an entire criminal code being voted on at once, a
sodomy law is defeated by the voters of the District of Columbia, the first
time voters said no to it.
1897 A
District of Columbia court ruled that, despite no adoptive language under
District law, all common-law crimes are in effect in the District, meaning
that sodomy can be prosecuted even without a sodomy law.
1909 The
earliest known published case in the U.S. in which a man solicits a police
officer for sex is reported in the District of Columbia.
1972 The
District government enters into a stipulation agreement not to prosecute
private, consensual sodomy.
1981 After
getting home rule from Congress, the District of Columbia Council passes a new
sex offenses law that repeals the sodomy law. Congress disallows the new law
with a one-house veto by the U.S. House. This is the first time that a local
law was disallowed by Congress without it having violated federal supremacy.
Later, the U.S. Supreme Court strikes down one-house vetoes, but Congress
still repeals the District law.
Florida
1842 Florida
becomes the first state in 123 years to make the penalty for sodomy death. It
is unclear why the penalty was raised, but no death sentences are carried out
in the state for it.
1845 Three
years after making sodomy a capital offense, Florida enacts a law forbidding
anyone convicted of sodomy from being a witness in a trial.
1921 Probably
the most homophobic language ever used in a sodomy opinion appears in a
decision from the Florida Supreme Court. “A discussion of the loathsome,
revolting crime would be of no edification to the people, nor interest to the
members of the bar. The creatures who are guilty are entitled to a
consideration of their case because they are called human beings and are
entitled to the protection of the laws.”
1943 The
Florida Supreme Court uses some unjudicious and ungrammatical language
concerning the defendant in a sodomy case, asking if “the action of a 76
year old, aged Indian War Veteran, feeble physically and mentally, in, after
having met the two girls of 11 and 13 years of age who solicited him, went to
his residence and there they both get on the bed, pull up their dresses and
drop down their panties, when he in turn on his back in the same bed allowed
them to diddle with his rag-like penis, unerectable, lifeless and useless
except to connect the bladder with the outside world for more than six years
since the death of his wife, utterly incapable of either penetration or
emission, and wad it like a rag into their mouths, and then, in a feeble and
aged condition impelled by the irresistible impulse, in turn he would kiss and
put his tongue in their little, though potentially influential and powerful
vaginas?”
1943 The
Florida Supreme Court finds that, if death were reinstated as the penalty for
consensual sodomy, it would be constitutional.
1960 A
unique opinion from the Attorney General of Florida decides that an act of
sodomy committed on an Indian reservation between two Indians or an Indian and
a non-Indian can not be prosecuted under state law.
1973 A
year-and-a-half after striking down the state’s felony “crime against
nature” law as unconstitutionally vague, the Florida Supreme Court, with no
changes in membership, upholds the state’s misdemeanor “unnatural and
lascivious acts” law, finding “against nature” too vague, but
“unnatural” perfectly understandable.
1975 A
trial court Miami is the first to find a Gay bathhouse a private place where
sexual activity is constitutionally protected.
Georgia
1817 Sodomy
first becomes a criminal offense in Georgia, 85 years after its organization
as a colony. It is the only one of the 13 colonies in which sodomy was legal
throughout the colonial period.
1833 Georgia
enacts a unique sodomy law (later copied by American Samoa) in which sodomy
was defined as “carnal knowledge and connection against the order of nature
by man with man, or in the same unnatural manner with woman.” Thus, what men
and women could legally do or not was determined by what it was possible for
two men to do. This law also clearly exempted Lesbians from prosecution.
1938 A
Georgia appellate court publishes the first known case concerning a sodomy
prosecution for interfemoral intercourse. The court says that this does not
constitute sodomy.
1939 The
Georgia Supreme Court is the first U.S. court to publish a sodomy case
involving two women. Because of Georgia’s unique 1833 sodomy law wording,
the Court finds that the women can not be prosecuted. The Georgia legislature
makes no effort to change the law.
1953 The
Georgia Supreme Court decides the only known case in which a mother sued the
employer of a man who engaged in sodomy with her son. She loses the case.
1968 Georgia
becomes the first Southern state to enact a comprehensive criminal code
revision following the publication of the Model Penal Code. It does not follow
the recommendation to repeal its sodomy law, but instead retains it as a
felony and makes it applicable to Lesbians as well.
1986 It is
the Georgia sodomy law that is subject of the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision
that homosexual sodomy is not a fundamental right.
Guam
1933 Sodomy
becomes a criminal offense in Guam with the promulgation of a criminal code by
the Naval Governor, the first in the U.S. to be enacted without legislation.
Hawaii
1841 A
series of laws is enacted while Hawaii still was an independent nation,
including a puzzling edict that “men and boys are forbidden to run in crowds
after new things. Whosoever does this in an indecent manner shall be punished
thus; he shall be taken to the house of confinement and remain till he pay a
rial [unit of currency], and be sent at liberty.”
1946 The
first sodomy-related case ever to reach the U.S. Supreme Court involves the
entrapment of a man by military police into solicitation. The Court refuses to
hear the case.
1983 The
Hawaii Supreme Court, in a non-sodomy case, discusses the state’s explicit
privacy rights amendment to the constitution and decides that it still does
not protect sodomy from prosecution, even though the state has repealed its
sodomy law. This means the state would be free to reenact a sodomy law at any
time.
Idaho
1913 The
Idaho Supreme Court rules that the state’s sodomy law that sets a minimum,
but no maximum penalty, permits a sentence of life imprisonment. This decision
is reaffirmed in 1992 by an appellate court that finds the possibility of life
imprisonment for private consensual activity to be reasonable.
1971 Idaho
becomes one of the earliest states to repeal its sodomy law, but outrage from
the Mormon and Catholic Churches causes a panic in the state. In 1972, the
entire old code, with the felony sodomy law, is reinstated, making Idaho the
first state ever to reinstate a repealed sodomy law.
1990 An
appellate court, following the lead of many other states, decides that sexual
activity occurring in an enclosed restroom stall is constitutionally
protected. The last name of the man arrested for masturbating in the stall was
Limberhand.
Illinois
1827 Illinois
is the first state to prohibit voting and jury service by anyone convicted of
sodomy.
1897 The
Illinois Supreme Court becomes the first in the nation to uphold a sodomy
conviction for an act of fellatio. The Court had to use an obscure law that
denied civil rights to anyone convicted of “sodomy or other crime against
nature.” This, the Court said, made it clear that there were many different
crimes against nature.
1913 The
Illinois Supreme Court becomes the first in the nation to hear a sodomy
conviction appeal for an act of cunnilingus. Just 16 years after saying that
fellatio violated the law, the Court went the double-standard route and found
that cunnilingus did not violate the law.
1961 In
enacting a comprehensive criminal code revision, Illinois becomes the first
state in the nation to repeal its consensual sodomy law.
Indiana
1807 An
extremely harsh sodomy law, including flogging, is signed by Governor William
Henry Harrison, the only sodomy law ever signed by a future U.S. President.
1827 Indiana
becomes the first state in the nation to make an accusation of sodomy a
specific ground for libel.
1881 A new
criminal code adds a provision to the sodomy law that it is illegal for a
person over twenty-one to assist someone under twenty-one with masturbation.
Cunnilingus is prosecuted in the state under this provision.
1907 Indiana
enacts the nation’s (and world’s) first sterilization law. The first law
covers all “confirmed criminals,” which could include those convicted of
sodomy.
1953 The
first published sodomy case under the federal Assimilative Crimes Act is in
Indiana. The law makes a crime on federal property located within a state
anything that is a crime under state law.
1964 Indiana
Supreme Court Justice Amos Jackson issues the first of what would turn out to
be many dissents in sodomy cases, he being the most outspokenly anti-sodomy
law Supreme Court Justice in the nation until his retirement in 1970.
Iowa
1892 Iowa
enacts its first statute against sodomy and the enacting law says that it will
become law upon publication in two stated newspapers. Though technically
either paper thus is given a veto power over the new law, it is published
promptly by both.
1904 The
Iowa Supreme Court is the first to get a sodomy defense claim of
“irresistable insane impulse.” The Court rejects the argument.
1907 A new
law requires first time offender male prisoners to be sent to the state
reformatory instead of prison, except for those convicted of four offenses,
one of them sodomy.
1925 The
Iowa Supreme Court is the first to get a sodomy defense of drunkeness. It
rejects the argument.
1970 Iowa
enacts a unique law requiring a coroner’s inquest into deaths caused by
“crimes against nature.”
Kansas
1969 In a
comprehensive criminal code revision, Kansas becomes the first state in the
nation to make its consensual sodomy law applicable only to people of the same
sex. The Judicial Council falsely reported to the legislature that this
language was “similar in wording” to those of other states revising their
codes during the same era.
1983 Kansas
becomes the first state to amend its incest law specifically to make same-sex
incest a crime.
1989 The
Kansas Supreme Court interprets the state’s sodomy law as not criminalizing
cunnilingus. The Kansas legislature acts swiftly to “correct” the
oversight, but accidentally includes heterosexual cunnilingus. Then they
“corrected” that error by rewording the law to re-legalize heterosexual
cunnilingus.
Kentucky
1918 A
contradictory guide for justices of the peace is published which defines
sodomy as 1) sodomy, buggery, and bestiality, which it claimed were
synonymous; 2) sodomy was not bestiality; and 3) sodomy was unnatural
copulation with man or beast, but it also was only unnatural copulation
between humans.
1954 Kentucky
becomes the first state adopting a state Uniform Code of Military Justice for
its militia, based on the federal code, to include a specific sodomy
provision. In 1970, it becomes the first state as well to repeal this explicit
provision.
Louisiana
1824 A
proposed criminal code for Louisiana by jurist Edward Livingston would have
repealed the state’s sodomy law, which would have been by the far the
earliest decriminalization in U.S. history. The legislature does not accept
the proposal.
1882 The
Louisiana Supreme Court is the first in the nation to reject a challenge to a
sodomy law as too vague to be constitutional.
1896 Louisiana
outlaws oral sex and the law to do so is the 69th to pass the legislature of
the year, so that the anti-oral sex law is known officially as Act 69.
1900 The
most amusing courtroom testimony to be reprinted in a sodomy case appears in a
case decided by the Louisiana Supreme Court with: The defendant “s____d the
____ of my son Ned until he has lost his mind.”
1942 The
earliest known law review criticism of a sodomy law appears in the Tulane
Law Review. The sodomy law was one of several laws in a new code that
deserved criticism, according to the article, but “space does not permit
their consideration.”
1962 Louisiana
becomes the first state to bifurcate its sodomy law to include an
“aggravated crime against nature” crime.
1982 Louisiana
becomes the first state to make solicitation for compensation of an act of
sodomy to be a completed act of sodomy.
2000 The
Louisiana Supreme Court, upholding the state’s sodomy law against a privacy
challenge, states that what the voters actually were saying in adopting a
privacy amendment to the state constitution is that they wanted to retain the
right of the legislature to make decisions on privacy for them.
Maine
1955 The
Maine Supreme Court is the first in the nation to rule that masturbating
another person does not violate the state’s sodomy law.
Maryland
1632 With
the adoption of its charter, Maryland becomes the only one of the original 13
colonies in which English law is unquestionably operative from the moment the
colony began.
1793 Maryland
enacts a unique sodomy law that permits those convicted of sodomy to be put to
work cleaning and repairing streets.
1809 Maryland
enacts the nation’s first law making murder committed as a consequence of
sodomy a capital offense.
1810 The
Maryland Court of Appeals publishes the first published sodomy case in U.S.
history when it disposes of a case challenging the sufficiency of the
defendant’s indictment.
1918 The
Attorney General of Maryland lists sodomy as among the crimes that showed a
lack of good moral character that would exclude someone from the military.
1972 A
criminal code revision commission recommends repealing the state’s sodomy
law, but establishing a discriminatory age of consent, something never before
recommended in a proposed code. The Maryland legislature does not follow
either recommendation.
1990 The
Maryland Court of Appeals, ignoring four previous decisions, rules that the
state’s sodomy law did not apply to heterosexual activity and never had.
Massachusetts
1648 Elizabeth
Johnson is the first woman known to be prosecuted for sexual relations with
another woman, in Massachusetts Bay Colony.
1697 The
new Massachusetts sodomy law refers to sodomy as being “against the very
light of nature,” the first statutory reference to nature in a sodomy law.
1821 The
Massachusetts Supreme Court decides the nation’s first obscenity case that
includes same-sex eroticism.
1921 The
Massachusetts Supreme Court issues the first reported decision in the nation
concerning sexual relations in a bath house.
1954 The
Massachusetts Supreme Court upholds the state’s sodomy law in the first case
in the nation to issue a broad challenge to it.
Michigan
1897 Michigan
enacts a unique law forbidding the debauching of boys, either by a male or a
female.
1903 Michigan
outlaws oral sex with the term “gross indecency,” a unique choice of words
in the U.S. This is the term in the law that sent Oscar Wilde to prison in
1895.
1935 Michigan
becomes the first state in the nation to enact what became known as a
“psychopathic offender” law. This law, usually limited to sexual
offenders, sentenced those convicted of any sexual offense, including private
consensual sodomy, to an often nightmare ordeal in state mental institutions,
often for many years.
Minnesota
1937 The
Minnesota Supreme Court upholds a sodomy conviction based on letters opened by
the post office, the first such situation reported in a U.S. sodomy case.
1963 The
Minnesota legislature passes a new criminal code, but fails to change any of
the sex offense sections, stating that they were just too controversial to
handle.
Mississippi
1890 Mississippi
adopts a unique provision in its new constitution to exclude the public from
trials for sodomy.
1942 The
Attorney General of Mississippi, revising the state’s code at the behest of
the legislature, retitles the sodomy provision from “Crime Against Nature”
to “Unnatural Intercourse” without editing the text of the law itself, and
later the Mississippi Supreme Court rules that this action expanded the reach
of the law.
Missouri
1846 The
Missouri Supreme Court, deciding a slander case involving an accusation of
sodomy, publishes the word “fuck” in its opinion.
1897 The
Missouri Supreme Court handles the first reported sodomy case in the United
States in which the defendant is a police officer.
1915 A
Missouri appellate court is the first to decide that being called a “cock
sucker” was actionable as slander.
1994 Missouri
enacts a new sodomy law, but it is worded in such a convoluted manner that
most attorneys think it criminalizes all sexual conduct, including by married
couples.
Montana
1938 The
Montana Supreme Court reverses a sodomy conviction that was based apparently
only on the close friendship of the two defendants.
1952 The
Montana Supreme Court reverses a sodomy conviction that seemed to be based on
a spanking given by one partner to the other, something not contemplated by
the state’s sodomy law.
1959 The
Montana Supreme Court reaffirms an earlier decision that fellatio is outlawed
by the state’s sodomy law, but the dissent written by Justice W. Hugh Adair
is the longest recorded in a sodomy case, some 12,000 words (the length of a
good-sized short story).
1972 The
Montana Constitutional Convention defeats the nation’s first explicit
attempt to create a sexual privacy amendment in the new constitution, but
includes a general privacy provision. Later, the Montana Supreme Court uses
the general amendment to strike down the state’s sodomy law.
1981 Montana
amends its sodomy law to include the possibility of a $50,000 fine (as well as
prison time), the largest fine ever in U.S. history for sodomy.
1991 Montana
amends its sodomy law to include the nation’s first explicit protection from
disclosure of treatment for a sexual transmitted disease to prosecutors.
Nebraska
1913 Nebraska
outlaws oral sex and the law to do so is the 69th to pass the legislature of
the year, so that the anti-oral sex law is known officially as Act 69.
1926 The
Nebraska Supreme Court overturns a sodomy conviction based on a deathbed
confession that the “victim” got syphilis from the defendant, the only
known such case in U.S. history.
1948 The
Nebraska Supreme Court rules that, in effect, some victims of sodomitical
assaults “deserve” the assault.
1977 Nebraska
repeals its sodomy law in a comprehensive criminal code revision that is
enacted by overriding the Governor’s veto. This is the only sodomy repeal
ever passed over a gubernatorial veto.
Nevada
1978 The
Nevada Supreme Court rules that the sodomy law is violated merely by licking a
penis, something other states have rejected, requiring actual penetration by
the mouth.
New
Hampshire
1962 A
legal journal reveals perhaps the most extreme misuse of a psychopathic
offender law in U.S. history: a 12-year-old boy was processed under the law
because he and a 9-year-old boy compared the length of their penises.
1975 A
repeal of the state’s consensual sodomy law is enacted by literally sneaking
it past the state’s outspokenly homophobic Governor. A revision of the
state’s rape laws created two new sections of law repealing two others, the
old rape law and the sodomy law. The Governor had not checked the repealed
sections before signing the bill.
New
Jersey
1704 The
New Jersey legislature, in an effort to quell public discontent with the
government, adopts a law pardoning everyone charged with any but 11 crimes.
Sodomy was not one of the 11 exempted, so all sodomy prosecutions are
abandoned of that date.
1796 In
adopting a new criminal code for the state, the New Jersey legislature makes
that state the first in the nation to use the term “crime against nature”
to refer to sodomy.
1898 In a
new criminal code, New Jersey permits any person to kill someone who was
“attempting to commit sodomy,” whether or not the person doing the killing
was the potential victim. Such
killer would be “guiltless, and shall be totally acquitted and
discharged.”
1923 The
New Jersey Supreme Court gets the first rudimentary privacy claim in a U.S.
sodomy case. Two men arrested for “private lewdness” with each other
claim that, because their activity occurred in private, it didn’t debauch
the public. The Court rejects
their argument and upholds their convictions.
1957 The
New Jersey Supreme Court rules that sodomy defendants have a right to have
their marital and parental status entered into their trials, something not
seen in any other state.
1960 A New
Jersey appellate court upholds the sodomy conviction of a right-wing
McCarthyite attorney for sex with various teenage males.
1976 The
New Jersey Supreme Court overturns the conviction of two men for having sex in
a car parked in a dark area along a state highway, saying that it was nearly
impossible for them to have been seen by anyone, the first such decision in
the U.S.
1978 After
passage of a new criminal code that repealed the state’s sodomy law, Senator
Joseph Maressa announces a crusade to reinstate consensual sodomy as a crime
only for acts between people of the same sex. After much public criticism, he
withdraws his bill.
New
Mexico
1961 The
New Mexico House of Representatives passes a proposed new criminal code that
includes a repeal of the consensual sodomy law, making it the first state ever
to have a repeal bill pass a house of a legislature. Unfortunately for
history, the Senate doesn’t go along and the new code fails to become law.
The bill also uses the unique term “variant sexual practice,” rather than
“deviant sexual practice,” as was preferred by other states.
1972 Appellate
court judge Lewis Sutin becomes the nation’s most outspoken anti-sodomy law
state court judge, following the retirement of Indiana Supreme Court Justice
Amos Jackson. Sutin continues on his crusade until the law is repealed in
1975.
New
York
1814 A New
York trial court publishes the earliest known slander case in U.S. history
involving an accusation of sodomy.
1839 A New
York trial court publishes the earliest known case in U.S. history in which a
person is found to have committed robbery by threatening a victim with an
accusation of sodomy.
1846 The
earliest known case of a civil servant being dismissed for making a
sodomitical solicitation occurs with a New York City police officer.
1903 Due
to the lingering beliefs from medieval times that sodomy always was assaultive
in nature, two men arrested for consensual sodomy with each other are charged
with sexually assaulting each other.
1950 New
York becomes the first state in the nation to reduce the penalty for
consensual sodomy from a felony to a misdemeanor.
1952 The
first in a series of court decisions in New York overturns convictions of men
for soliciting undercover police officers to go back to their place for
“fun.” The courts say that “fun” can be any number of things. This
opens a hole in the state’s solicitation laws.
1958 A
court overturns the disorderly conduct conviction of a man for soliciting and
fondling an undercover police officer in a restroom because there was no
evidence that there was an attempt to breach the peace, which the court found
to be required by the law.
1961 The
state’s highest court interprets the portion of state’s sodomy law
covering anal sex to criminalize the acts only of the partner inserting his
penis into his partner’s anus. The
following year, the New York legislature amends the sodomy law to cover both
partners.
1965 In
adopting a new criminal code, the New York legislature makes that state the
first in the nation to adopt a statutory exemption to the sodomy law for
married couples.
1969 A
federal judge is the first in the nation to be presented with a sodomy
prosecution of actors for engaging in sex on a public stage.
1997 New
York is the first state to have a prosecution for sodomy under its state
Universal Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) that covers the national guard.
North
Carolina
1854 North
Carolina becomes the last state in the nation to abolish references from its
sodomy law to the old English legal custom of benefit of clergy.
1856 A
guidebook for justices of the peace on North Carolina advocates the Napoleonic
Code for the state. In France,
the Napoleonic Code had decriminalized consensual sodomy.
1954 A law
review recommends amending the state’s sodomy law to exclude married couples
from the statute’s coverage, but no one else.
1964 Federal
judge J. Braxton Craven issues a sarcastic opinion ridiculing the North
Carolina sodomy law, calling into question trial procedures in sodomy cases,
the penalty prescribed by the law, and even the wisdom of outlawing consensual
sodomy.
North
Dakota
1917 The
most bizarre language ever found in a U.S. sodomy case is in a concurring
opinion in a case in which a conviction for heterosexual cunnilingus is
upheld. The judge complained that the girl involved “was not given even a
peanut.”
Northern
Mariana Islands
1952 Sodomy
is outlawed by Executive Order of the Commissioner of the trusteeship set up
by the United Nations. This is the only such U.S. law ever enacted by a
civilian executive.
Ohio
1815 Ohio
outlaws adultery, and one of its provisions may prohibit sexual relations
between women, when it forbids married women from having sexual intercourse
with other “person,” whereas the prohibition for men is limited to
“other women.” The law lasts nine years before being changed.
1876 Ohio
becomes the first state in the nation to outlaw the possession of “sex
toys.”
1885 Ohio
outlaws sodomy for the first time, and there is evidence that the law was
enacted solely as a political embarrassment for the Governor, who was hinted
as being Gay by an opponent newspaper.
1886 An
Ohio appellate court becomes the first in the nation to rule that two women
can not be prosecuted for sodomy.
1895 An
Ohio court is the first in the nation to decide that an act of extramarital
sodomy constitutes adultery.
1908 Ohio
becomes the first state in the nation to prohibit probation for anyone
convicted of sodomy.
1953 Columbus
police set up a national dragnet to catch a man who engaged in consensual
sexual relations with seven other men. The New York Times assists by
opening mail sent to a box at the newspaper.
1957 An
Ohio court, handling a divorce case, is the first in the nation to find a
constitutional right of married couples to engage in sodomy.
1965 An
Ohio appellate court is the first in the nation to strike down a statute
banning solicitation for an “unnatural sex act,” the court noting that the
term is impossible to define.
1965 The
first case in U.S. federal court raising Civil War-era civil rights statutes
to block prosecution on sodomy charges is lost when a judge rules against the
defendant.
1972 Ohio
enacts a new criminal code and repeals its sodomy law. This code is the first
in the nation to adopt gender-neutral sexual assault laws, and the first to
adopt “modern” references to sexual activity, omitting references to
“perversion” or “unnatural.”
Oklahoma
1890 Oklahoma’s
first criminal code makes explicit that married couples can be prosecuted for
marital sodomy.
1935 An
Oklahoma appellate court becomes the first court in the nation to rule that an
act of cunnilingus is a “crime against nature.”
1986 The
Court of Criminal Appeals rules that the state’s sodomy law can not be applied
constitutionally to people of the opposite sex. In 1988, another court rules
that the decision applies to “consenting adults,” apparently regardless of
gender. Just two weeks later, the same court clarifies that it is applicable
only to “consensual, heterosexual” activity.
1988 Oklahoma
enacts a state RICO law that applies to businesses involved in criminal
activity, including sodomy. This apparently can be used against bath houses.
Oregon
1843 Early
Oregon settlers adopt a code of laws based on Iowa law, but it is unclear if
the Iowa code adopted is the 1838 code that had Michigan’s sodomy law, or
the 1843 code that didn’t have any sodomy law.
1894 A Gay
male couple is reported to police by a neighbor and one is sent to jail.
1913 Oregon
adopts a uniquely worded new sodomy law: “If any person shall commit sodomy
or the crime against nature, or any act or practice of sexual perversity,
either with mankind or beast, or sustain osculatory relations with the private
parts of any man, woman or child, or permit such relations to be sustained
with his or her private parts, such person shall upon conviction thereof, be
punished by imprisonment in the penitentiary not less than one year nor more
than fifteen years.”
1913 Oregon
enacts a law requiring the sexual sterilization of “sexual perverts,” who
are defined as those “addicted” to sodomy. A group of prominent citizens
forces a referendum on the new law and voters repeal it by a 56%-44% margin.
Four years later, the Oregon legislature ignores this vote and reenacts
the law.
1955 Oregon
enacts the first law in the nation forbidding the kidnapping of a child for
purposes of engaging in sodomy.
1966 The
Oregon Supreme Court upholds a sodomy conviction based on a neighbor reporting
a Gay couple to police.
1988 The
Oregon Court of Appeals issues two decisions that all but obliterate the
state’s law against public indecency when it reverses convictions for
masturbating openly in public restrooms.
Pennsylvania
1682 A
criminal code enacted in this Quaker colony sets the maximum penalty for
sodomy at six months in jail, the only non-capital sodomy law in the American
colonies. This leniency ends when
Quakers lose control of the colony.
1700 Pennsylvania’s
new sodomy law, limited only to men, sets the penalty for a first offense at
life imprisonment, with a flogging possible every three months during the
first year of imprisonment and, if married, he was to be castrated and his
wife offered a divorce.
1722 Pennsylvania
enacts the first law in the colonies requiring the posting of a bond for the
good behavior of convicted sodomites being brought into the colony.
