Last edited: February 12, 2005


St. Joseph’s Affirms Offer to Santorum

Despite faculty and student opposition, the university did not rescind an invitation to the senator to speak at graduation.

Philadelphia Inquirer, April 26, 2003
P.O. Box 8263, Philadelphia, PA 19101
Fax: 215-854-4483
Email: Inquirer.opinion@phillynews.com

By James M. O’Neill, Inquirer Staff Writer

LOWER MERION—St. Joseph’s University trustees yesterday reaffirmed an invitation to embattled Sen. Rick Santorum to speak at commencement next month, despite opposition from faculty and a rare campus protest by students.

About 125 students, along with several priests and faculty, protested silently on campus yesterday, holding signs that said “Not @ my graduation” and “Senator Santorum does not represent the best in us,” as the trustees’ executive committee discussed the invitation issued back in January and an honorary degree the school plans to bestow on the senator.

Santorum, the third-ranking Republican in the Senate, engendered controversy this week when he equated gay sex with polygamy, incest and adultery and called homosexuality “antithetical to a healthy, stable, traditional family.”

Santorum is Catholic, and his controversial comments seemed to follow Catholic teaching. The church teaches that gays should be treated with respect, but that homosexual acts are “intrinsically disordered” and morally wrong. In his controversial remarks, Santorum said, “I have no problem with homosexuality. I have a problem with homosexual acts.”

Still, the protesters at St. Joseph’s, a Catholic institution, said Santorum’s comments offended. “He does not seem to represent the values of our university,” said junior Kera Walter.

Many students at the Jesuit university on City Avenue said class discussion is routinely woven with lessons about the importance of social justice and of making the campus welcoming to all people, no matter their ethnicity or sexual orientation. They said Santorum’s comments did not reflect that call to openness.

Senior Guy Palumbo said that while a college campus is meant to foster an open exchange of conflicting viewpoints, commencement is different. “Having an extremist from the left or the right speak and politicize commencement is inappropriate,” he said.

The Rev. H. Cornell Bradley, a Jesuit and campus minister, stood in solidarity with the students. “Graduation is a celebration for the students, and to have a controversial speaker interferes with that,” he said. “The attention would be taken away from the students’ achievement.”

St. Joseph’s spokesman Joseph Lunardi emerged from the trustees’ two-hour meeting, acknowledging the controversy but saying the trustees chose not to rescind Santorum’s invitation.

Lunardi said the trustees thought they should remain consistent with the school’s commitment to openness. “We’re trying to send a message that all views are welcome here, regardless of their popularity,” Lunardi said.

“This many not be a popular path, but if we stand for tolerance, we can’t be intolerant of anyone, and we hope all involved will keep that in mind.”

The trustees also suggested in a statement that an academic forum, rather than commencement, is the more appropriate setting for public-policy debate.

Santorum spokeswoman Erica Clayton Wright said that Santorum was on a “private schedule” for the weekend, and that she could not comment on the St. Joseph’s decision.

Top administrators at St. Joseph’s generated a list of possible graduation speakers earlier this year, and a director of student life then polled some students about the list. An Irish tenor outpolled Santorum, but when the singer was unavailable for the May 18 graduation, the invitation was offered to the senator.

Santorum’s invitation generated opposition even before his comments about gays. Earlier this semester, some faculty expressed their displeasure, arguing that Santorum’s support for capital punishment and for the Iraq war clashed with Catholic teaching and Pope John Paul II’s statements on both issues.

Commencement speakers frequently become lightning rods for protest. In 1999, Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist Anna Quindlen withdrew as commencement speaker at Villanova University because of objections to her support of abortion rights. Quindlen said she did not want to “ruin the day or cast a shadow” on the graduation ceremony.

This spring, Holy Cross College in Massachusetts is under fire from some key alumni and benefactors for its decision to grant an honorary degree to Philadelphia native and television commentator Chris Matthews because of Matthews’ support for abortion rights, which counters Catholic teaching.

  • Contact staff writer James M. O’Neill at 610-313-8012 or joneill@phillynews.com. Inquirer staff writer Mark Schogol contributed to this article.  


Shame on St. Joseph’s

Philadelphia Inquirer, May 2, 2003
P.O. Box 8263, Philadelphia, PA 19101
Fax: 215-854-4483
Email: Inquirer.opinion@phillynews.com
Letters

As a graduate of St. Joseph’s University (Class of 1980) who gave the commencement address and now a psychotherapist, I am outraged that my alma mater has chosen to honor a man whose remarks last week make him akin to a bully in a suit.

Inviting U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum to receive an honorary degree is as repulsive as awarding George Wallace a degree at the height of civil unrest and riots in the 1960s.

I am appalled that the institution I love, which prides itself on its commitment to social and economic justice, has chosen to confer a degree on a man who uses his status and office to bash gay people.

Yes, disinviting Sen. Santorum would incur criticism and perhaps some negative publicity, but if Jesus had based his actions on what other people would think, there would not be a university on City Avenue that professes to be Christian. Shame on you!

—Greg Rossi, Yardley


[Home] [News] [Lawrence v. Texas] [Santorum] [Spreading Santorum]